Soft Amish-made Mattresses

Some sleepers want softness without giving up support, that middle ground between sinking in and staying on top. Monarch Rest Plush mattresses cover it, rating roughly 1 to 5 on an 8-point firmness scale, from nearly cloud-soft to a softer-medium feel with more response. They tend to suit side sleepers who need cushioning at the shoulders and hips, along with combination sleepers who shift positions through the night. The comfort layers vary by model: breathable Talalay latex, gel-infused memory foam for cooling, or high-density polyurethane foam for lasting support, often layered together rather than piled on cheap springs. The range spans the whole lineup, from the budget-friendly Quiet Night series to the exotic Fuchsia line, and double-sided options like Elite Plush and Resilience Plush flip and rotate for even wear. Every Monarch Rest mattress is handcrafted in Sugarcreek, Ohio and backed by a 20-year warranty. Browse our Plush mattresses below.