The Perfect Choice Series by Monarch Rest
The revolutionary choice for adaptable comfort, where flexibility meets lasting quality.
The Perfect Choice Series represents the industry’s only mattress with a replaceable topper system, combining exceptional durability with unmatched versatility. For those who want the freedom to adapt their comfort over time, Perfect Choice mattresses feature a superior offset coil innerspring core (12.5 gauge steel) that provides more flexibility and support than traditional Bonnell coils, double-sided construction that allows regular rotation and flipping to extend mattress life, and double-edge coil side supports (12-14 depending on size) that deliver superior edge strength and sleeping surface. Every Perfect Choice mattress is hand-assembled in Sugarcreek, Ohio, where skilled Amish artisans build each one with meticulous attention to detail, using high-density 1.8+ weight foam padding that outlasts industry-standard materials by years. Available in two topper options—Perfect Choice Gel with replaceable gel-infused memory foam (Extra Plush) and Perfect Choice Latex with replaceable natural Talalay latex in three firmnesses (Extra Plush, Plush, or Firm)—these innovative reversible mattresses let you change your comfort based on season, preference, or life changes. We stand behind this quality with an industry-leading 20-year limited warranty (10 years full coverage, 10 years prorated), with the unique advantage that your topper is also replaceable under warranty. All Perfect Choice mattresses are 13″ tall and deliver the adaptability that indecisive sleepers dream of. Built to be flipped, rotated, customized, and cherished for years to come!
Introducing the Perfect Choice Latex and Perfect Choice Gel
Experience the revolutionary Perfect Choice Latex, featuring the industry’s only replaceable topper system with a 3-inch natural Talalay latex layer that lets you change your comfort preference whenever life changes. This 13-inch two-sided mattress combines a superior offset coil innerspring core with double-edge side supports for exceptional edge strength. Choose from three latex firmness options—Extra Plush (level 2), Plush (level 4), or Firm (level 6)—and swap your topper anytime for perfect adaptability. The breathable natural Talalay latex (sourced from rubber tree sap) offers hypoallergenic, antibacterial properties with the longest-lasting comfort of any mattress material. Simply rotate and flip every six months to maintain even wear. Backed by our industry-leading 20-year limited warranty (10 years full, 10 years prorated)—with the unique advantage that your replaceable topper is covered under warranty.
Experience the revolutionary Perfect Choice Gel, featuring the industry’s only replaceable topper system with 2 inches of gel-infused memory foam (4 lb. density) that delivers extremely plush pressure relief. This 13-inch double-sided mattress combines gel-infused comfort with our superior 12.5 gauge offset coil innerspring system and reinforced double-edge side supports (12-14 depending on size). Available in Extra Plush (firmness level 1) for cloud-like comfort. Simply rotate and flip every six months to maintain even wear, and replace your gel topper whenever you want to refresh your sleep surface. Backed by our industry-leading 20-year limited warranty (10 years full, 10 years prorated)—with the unique advantage that your replaceable topper is covered under warranty.
The Anatomy of the Perfect Choice Mattress
Look inside an Perfect Choice mattress and you'll see what sets it apart...
A Quarter Per Night Could Change Your Life. Your $5 Coffee? Not So Much
Most of us don’t think twice about spending $5 on coffee. That’s $1,825 a year. And that’s fine! We all have our daily habits that keep us going. But when it comes to a mattress, we sometimes hesitate at the upfront cost without considering what we’re actually getting for our money.
So let’s look at it differently.
The average person spends about 26 years sleeping in their lifetime. You’re going to spend that time no matter what. The only question is how well you’ll sleep, and how you’ll feel when you wake up.
With a quality Monarch Rest mattress, backed by our 20-year warranty, you’re looking at 7,300 nights of sleep. When you break that down, you’re spending roughly 50 cents a night on quality sleep backed with a warranty to ensure you’ll love it.
When was the last time your coffee came with a warranty?
But here’s what makes this investment really worthwhile. Good sleep doesn’t just affect those 8 hours. It sets up your entire day.
Research shows that poor sleep costs the average person about 11 days of productivity each year. Your mattress is either helping you or hurting you here. A worn-out or poorly made mattress leaves you waking up tired, sore, and dragging through your day. Less energy for work, less patience with loved ones, less enjoyment of life.
A well-made mattress, on the other hand, helps you wake up actually rested. You’re more productive, more present, and have more energy for the things that matter. That benefit shows up every single day for years.
So for about 50 cents per night, you’re investing in better days.
Think about it this way: a modest nightly investment in a mattress that supports 8 hours of restoration and powers 16 hours of living. That’s 7,300 opportunities to wake up ready for whatever life brings.
When you invest in your sleep, you invest in your life.
CUSTOMER REVIEWS
FAQ ABOUT AMISH MADE MATTRESSES
Q. What makes Monarch Rest mattresses different from big-box store brands?
A: Every Monarch Rest mattress is handcrafted in Sugarcreek, Ohio by skilled artisans using premium materials. We use heavier 12.5-13 gauge steel (vs. industry standard 14.5), high-density 1.8+ weight foam (vs. 1.2 standard), and water-based lamination adhesive. Plus our 20-year warranty is industry-leading. You’re getting American-made, Amish craftsmanship with a small team that ensures quality control at every step.
Q: How do I know which firmness level is right for me?
A: Firmness preference depends on sleep position, body type, and personal comfort. Generally: side sleepers prefer plush (2-4), back sleepers prefer medium (4-6), and stomach sleepers prefer firm (6-8). We use a 1-8 scale where 1 is most plush and 8 is most firm.Â
Q: What does your 20-year warranty cover?
A: Our warranty covers workmanship defects, material failures, and body impressions. For most models: the first 10 years provide free repair/replacement for impressions over 0.5″ (you only pay transportation), and years 11-20 provide 50% credit toward repair/replacement for impressions over 1″. This is how we back up our commitment to building mattresses that last.
Q: How often should I rotate or flip my mattress?
A: Single-sided mattresses should be rotated head-to-foot every 3 months. Double-sided mattresses should be rotated AND flipped every 6 months (Spring and Fall are easy reminders). Regular rotation and flipping prevent uneven wear and help your investment last the full 20 years.
Â
Q: Do Amish really make these mattresses by hand?
A: Absolutely. A small team of skilled Amish craftspeople in Sugarcreek, Ohio handcrafts each mattress using professional tools and old-world attention to detail—every mattress gets individual care from people who’ve been perfecting this craft for decades.
Discover the Best Handmade Mattress for Your Perfect Night’s Sleep
Searching for the best mattress that combines luxury mattress comfort with affordable mattress pricing? Monarch Rest delivers heirloom quality mattresses handcrafted by skilled Amish artisans in Sugarcreek, Ohio since 1991. Whether you need a firm mattress for back support, a plush memory foam mattress for pressure relief, or a responsive hybrid mattress with pocket coils, our American made collection offers every sleep style with an industry-leading 20-year warranty. Every Monarch Rest mattress is built with obsessive attention to detail, from our 1.8+ density foam (twice as durable as industry standard) to our 12.5-gauge steel innersprings (stronger than typical 14.5-gauge wire), ensuring your investment delivers decades of comfort, not just years.
Handmade Craftsmanship You Can Sleep On for Generations
Unlike mass-produced mattresses, every Monarch Rest mattress is individually hand-assembled by a small team of 10 skilled craftspeople who prioritize quality over speed. Our Swiss-German craftsmanship tradition means you’re not just buying a comfortable mattress—you’re investing in a sleep system engineered for longevity with natural Talalay latex, gel-infused memory foam, New Zealand wool, and Mongolian cashmere options. From our budget-friendly Quiet Night series to our crown jewel Fuchsia collection, we offer double-sided flippable designs, and replaceable topper systems. When you choose American made Monarch Rest, you’re supporting family-owned manufacturing while getting a quality mattress backed by a 20-year warranty that proves we build mattresses to last…not to be replaced. Experience the difference that true handmade craftsmanship makes in your sleep.